Bigler Stouffer II is
set to receive a three-drug lethal injection at 10 a.m. Thursday, Dec. 9, 2021,
at the Oklahoma State Penitentiary in McAlester, for the 1985 slaying of an
Oklahoma City-area teacher. (Oklahoma Department of Corrections via AP, File)
On
this date, December 9, 2021, Bigler Jobe Stouffer II was
executed by lethal injection in Oklahoma. He was convicted murdering Linda
Reaves on January 24, 1985.
If the criminal taking of a human life does not merit forfeiture of
one's own life, then what value have we placed on the life taken? - Pat
Buchanan
Oklahoma prepares for execution
on Thursday of Bigler Stouffer
By Adrian O'Hanlon III and Janelle Stecklein CNHI
Oklahoma
McALESTER, Okla. — Linda Reaves was excited about
two things in 1985, her sister remembers: becoming an aunt and teaching
elementary students in Oklahoma.
Reaves, 35, who taught school in Putnam City, near
Oklahoma City, was fatally shot in 1985. Her boyfriend, Doug Ivens, was
seriously wounded in the attack.
Nearly 37 years later, Reaves’ family members await
justice. Bigler Stouffer’s family members and defenders, meanwhile, claim it
would be wrong to execute him, alleging there are problems with some of the
evidence.
Stouffer, now 79, is scheduled to die at 10 a.m.
Thursday in the Oklahoma State Penitentiary in McAlester.
He was sentenced to death by two juries 18 years
apart. His first conviction was thrown out over a question of ineffective legal
representation. Stouffer was convicted a second time and resentenced to death
again in 2003.
Oklahoma Gov. Kevin Stitt denied Stouffer clemency
last week, despite a 3-2 recommendation from the state’s Pardon and Parole
Board to commute his sentence to life in prison without parole because of
concerns some board members voiced about the state’s ability to carry out
executions. The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals also denied Stouffer an
emergency motion for a stay of execution.
Late Wednesday, he still hoped for a last-minute
reprieve from the U.S. Supreme Court, which he had asked to grant an emergency
application for a stay.
Stouffer’s family members, reached Wednesday, had
no additional comment, and said they preferred to spend the time in final
conversation via phone with the condemned.
Reaves’ sister, Dana Wheat, also was unavailable
for comment Wednesday, but said during the recent clemency hearing that she was
pregnant with her first child at the time of the murder — and knew her sister
was looking forward to becoming an aunt. Wheat also said during that hearing
that the family is scared of Stouffer, and that she’ll never forget Linda.
“It never leaves me,” Wheat said. “I’m going to see her face … I just hear her screaming ‘No’.
And she didn’t have time for a prayer, either.”
Prosecutors said Stouffer went to Ivens' home to
borrow a gun before he fatally shot Reaves and wounded Ivens. They said
Stouffer was dating Ivens' ex-wife, and that he was trying to get access to
Ivens’ $2 million life insurance policy.
Officials with the Oklahoma Attorney General’s
Office testified at Stouffer’s clemency hearing that Ivens and Reaves were in
love and saw a future together.
Reaves’ family said they still mourn her loss — and
that Ivens always put a decorated Christmas tree at her grave because it was
her favorite holiday.
Family members also testified that Reaves was a
kind and beautiful presence who was an excellent artist and occasionally sent
them drawings and sketches.
Christy Miller, an assistant district attorney,
told the Pardon and Parole Board that this was the first death penalty case she
had ever tried in 2003, adding that she has never forgotten Ivens’ voice on the
911 call and the trauma that Stouffer inflicted on “a completely innocent
woman.”
Ivens has since died, but all he wanted was justice
for Reaves, his sisters, Debby Wiens and Pam Korgan, both said when testifying
recently before the Pardon and Parole Board.
“The evil that this man has done, has
perpetrated and seeped into the lives of many others,” Korgan said.
“And this evil has caused fear. It has caused
confusion. It has caused pain, and it has changed lives forever.”
Miller said Reaves’ last moments were “filled with
terror” as she watched her boyfriend get shot, tried to defend herself. Miller
also argued that the killer tried to frame the attack as a murder-suicide.
“BJ Stouffer has spent the last 36 years
trying to fool everybody in the criminal justice system,” Miller said.
But the Rev. Howard Potts, pastor at Anchor Baptist
Church in Muskogee, believes Stouffer should not be executed.
He said Stouffer was known as “Buddy” to friends
because anyone who knew him was a “buddy.” The name stuck with him all through
school.
Potts could not be reached for additional comment
Wednesday, but in previous remarks touted Stouffer’s athletic prowess and said
teammates could always count on him. Following graduation, Stouffer went into
business, and surprised his friends by making good money.
During his first trial in 1985, many were astounded
that Stouffer had been accused, Potts said.
And, in a petition presented to Stitt recently,
Stouffer’s defenders, citing a forensic expert, point out that there should
have been “substantial blood on the clothing of the person responsible for the
contact gunshot wound to Linda Reaves’s head. There was no blood on Mr.
Stouffer’s clothing.”
Family members, who presented Stitt with a petition
they said was signed by 10,000 people opposing the execution, also have said
publicly they do not believe there has been an adequate investigation of the
case, despite two trials.
And, in the 37 years he was on death row, Stouffer
has faced three other execution dates, which were cancelled, Potts said.
“This is not a righteous kill,” Potts said at the
time.
Potts said he’s provided spiritual counseling to
Stouffer since 2017, and now runs some of “his errands” on the outside. He said
Stouffer now serves as an advocate for prisoners who are to be executed.
“He is (a) strong believer in the Christian faith,
and really believes that God has been in control … And, his 37 years on death
row, he has given testimony that God was in control and has been orchestrating
all through it.”
Stouffer’s son, Bigler Job Stouffer III, testified
at the hearing that he feels horrible for all the families who were involved,
but loves his father, who has now spent the vast majority of his life behind
bars.
He said he believes the facts show that this case
is not as clear cut as many believe, and that he hopes others will view it
without emotion.
Stouffer also said at his parole board hearing that
Reaves was dead when he arrived and Ivens was shot as he and Ivens struggled
over the gun.
Parole board members who opposed Stouffer’s
execution primarily questioned whether Oklahoma's recent history with lethal
injections violates the 8th Amendment after John Grant vomited and convulsed
several times while being put to death in October.
Grant, convicted of killing a prison cafeteria
worker, became Oklahoma’s first execution since a hiatus in 2015 after scrutiny
stemming from a series of problematic lethal injections.
Clayton Lockett, convicted in 2000 of murder and
several other charges, writhed for nearly an hour on a gurney during his 2014
lethal injection. A state investigation later found the IV in Lockett’s groin
came loose and prolonged his death.
The state then used an drug not approved at the
time of the 2015 execution of Charles Warner, who was convicted in the rape and
murder of an infant.
Oklahoma’s then-general counsel, Steve Mullins,
told prison officials to proceed using the same mixture used in Warner’s
execution for the lethal injection of death row inmate Richard Glossip — but
then-Oklahoma Governor Mary Fallin intervened by issuing a stay.
The state uses midazolam to first render the inmate
unconscious, then vecuronium bromide as a muscle relaxant, and finally
potassium chloride to stop the heart.
Oklahoma resumed lethal injections in October using
the same three-drug combination used in Lockett’s 2014 execution.
Defense attorneys have challenged the effectiveness
of midazolam — but federal appellate judges wrote Stouffer didn't address key
factors in his appeal.
According to the Oklahoma Coalition to Abolish the
Death Penalty, it costs taxpayers from $2 million to $5 million per death
sentence, for trials and appeals. Life sentences cost an average of $1 million
— or 40 years at $25,000 per year.
INTERNET SOURCE: https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=361471949116312&id=100057605302283
https://www.mcalesternews.com/news/local_news/oklahoma-prepares-for-execution-on-thursday-of-bigler-stouffer/article_84b0cef6-f14a-5de9-96c5-ef8b46b2a1fd.html
|
FILE - This undated
photo provided by the Oklahoma Department of Corrections shows Bigler Jobe
Stouffer II. Bigler Stouffer II is set to receive a three-drug lethal injection
at 10 a.m. Thursday, Dec. 9, 2021, at the Oklahoma State Penitentiary in
McAlester, for the 1985 slaying of an Oklahoma City-area teacher. (Oklahoma
Department of Corrections via AP, File) |
Oklahoma executes man for 1985 slaying of schoolteacher
By
SEAN MURPHY
December
10, 2021
McALESTER,
Okla. (AP) — Oklahoma executed a man Thursday for the 1985 shooting death of an
Oklahoma City-area schoolteacher after courts rejected his claim that the
state’s lethal injection method would result in unconstitutional pain and
suffering.
Bigler
Stouffer II, 79, received a three-drug lethal injection at the Oklahoma State
Penitentiary in McAlester.
Stouffer
was the first person executed in Oklahoma since John Grant convulsed
on the gurney and vomited during his lethal injection in October as the
state ended a six-year execution moratorium brought on by concerns over its
protocols.
Thursday’s
execution process that began at 10 a.m. appeared to go more smoothly. After
receiving lethal drugs, Stouffer was declared unconscious at 10:07 a.m., and
his breaths became shallower at 10:09 a.m. He was declared dead at 10:16 a.m.
Oklahoma
Attorney General John O’Connor said in statement that the execution “was
carried out with zero complications.” The Rev. Howard Potts, who was in the
death chamber with Stouffer, said Stouffer “was totally at peace.”
Stouffer’s
last words were: “My request is that my father forgive them. Thank you.”
Stouffer
has maintained his innocence in the attack that left Linda Reaves dead and her
boyfriend, Doug Ivens, seriously injured. He and his attorneys argued in court
filings that the state’s three-drug execution method poses a risk of
unconstitutional pain and suffering and that Stouffer should be included among
other death row plaintiffs in a federal lawsuit challenging the protocols. But his
request for a stay of execution was denied by a federal district judge and
the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit. A final appeal with the U.S.
Supreme
Court was denied Thursday morning, less than two hours before the scheduled
execution
Stouffer
was convicted and sentenced to death in 2003 after his first conviction and
death sentence were overturned. At a
parole board hearing last month, he said Ivens was shot as the two men fought
over a gun at Ivens’ home, and that Reaves was dead when he arrived.
“I
am totally innocent of the murder of Linda Reaves and my heart goes out to the
family of Linda Reaves that have suffered as a result of her murder,” Stouffer
told the board during a video appearance from prison.
Prosecutors
said Stouffer went to the home to borrow the gun from Ivens, then fatally shot
Reaves and wounded Ivens to gain access to Ivens’ $2 million life insurance
policy. At the time, Stouffer was dating Ivens’ ex-wife.
Despite
being shot three times with a .38-caliber pistol, including once in the face,
Ivens survived and testified against Stouffer. Ivens has since died.
“Stouffer’s
heinous actions against Doug and Linda, his lies and manipulations in the years
to follow, and his complete lack of sorrow and remorse for the hurt he caused
should dictate one conclusion — the jury’s death sentence must be carried out,”
attorneys for the state wrote in asking the Pardon and Parole Board to reject
Stouffer’s request for clemency.
Several
members of the board voiced concerns about the state’s ability to humanely
execute people. But Republican Gov. Kevin Stitt ultimately
rejected the board’s recommendation that Stitt commute Stouffer’s sentence
to life in prison without parole.
Reaves’
cousin, Rodney Thomson, spoke to reporters after Stouffer’s execution, saying
the killing had consumed his family members. He thanked the attorney general
and staff and other prosecutors and investigators who worked on the case.
Bigler
Stouffer is set to be executed today.
-This is the woman who was murdered, Linda Reaves.
-Court records say she was dating Doug Ivens and Stouffer
was dating Ivens’ estranged wife.
-On January 24, 1985, they say Stouffer went to Ivens to
borrow a gun to deal with a prowler who had been by the estranged wife’s home.
-They say Ivens was worried about her safety and the
safety of his young daughters, so he got a gun and handed it to Stouffer.
-They say Stouffer then used that gun to shoot Ivens
twice, then walked over to the couch where Reaves was and shot her twice in the
head, then walked back over to Ivens and shot him in the face.
-Ivens survived and called 911 and said Stouffer had shot
them both and later testified at the trial.
-Reaves had been a school teacher in Putnam City.
-Staffer’s attorneys argue the scene wasn’t properly
processed because officers went with the information from the 911 call.
-All appeals have been denied and the execution is set for
10 am.
“Today
we witnessed the law of the land carried out on behalf of my cousin,” Thomson
read from a statement. “Although long in coming, justice has prevailed.”
Stitt
did grant
clemency to another man on death row, Julius Jones, last month just hours
before his scheduled execution, commuting his sentence to life in prison
without the possibility of parole. That case had drawn outcry and protests over
doubts about his guilt in the slaying of a businessman more than 20 years ago.
Executions
in Oklahoma have typically been held in the evenings, but prison officials
moved Stouffer’s execution to 10 a.m. to make it easier for the prison to
return to normal operations, said Department of Corrections spokesman Josh
Ward.
Oklahoma
had one of the nation’s busiest death chambers until problems in
2014 and 2015 led to a de facto moratorium. Richard Glossip was just
hours away from being executed in September 2015 when prison officials
realized they received the wrong lethal drug. It was later learned the same
wrong drug had been used to execute
another man in January 2015.
The
drug mix-ups followed a botched execution in April 2014 in which inmate Clayton
Lockett struggled on a gurney before dying 43 minutes into his lethal
injection — and after the state’s prisons chief ordered executioners to stop.
INTERNET
SOURCE: https://apnews.com/article/executions-oklahoma-oklahoma-city-mcalester-010c24e70725c52f787f9fdb7d73cbf9
Brutal facts have immense power; they etched deep marks in my psyche.
Those who commit such atrocities, I concluded, forfeit their own right to live.
We tarnish their memory of the dead and heed needless misery on their surviving
families by letting the perpetrators live.
– Alex Kozinski
RELATED
LINKS:
VFFDP:
Grandmother of 3-year-old Del City murder
victim supports the death penalty, calls for justice
https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=2119274974890529&id=1299628893521812
https://www.facebook.com/koco5/posts/10158336825186782
https://www.koco.com/article/grandmother-three-year-old-del-city-murder-victim-death-penalty-justice/38335995
'Satan is real' says mum after killer
rapist buried daughter then joined search
https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=2117861261698567&id=1299628893521812
https://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/world-news/satan-real-says-mum-after-25495596
Parents of Murdered Children Demand
Steeper Penalties for Killing Kids
https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=2118661191618574&id=1299628893521812
https://news.wttw.com/2021/11/16/parents-murdered-children-demand-steeper-penalties-killing-kids
https://vk.com/wall-184585082_352
Bigler
Stouffer executed for 1985 murder of elementary teacher
https://www.facebook.com/LifesparkJustice/posts/3079573239029697
https://kfor.com/news/local/execution-scheduled-for-oklahoma-death-row-inmate-bigler-stouffer/
Court denies
stay of execution for Oklahoma death row inmate Bigler Stouffer
https://www.facebook.com/LifesparkJustice/posts/3078459852474369
https://www.koco.com/article/court-denies-stay-of-execution-bigler-stouffer/38449189
OTHER
LINKS:
See also