On
this date, September 21, 2011, an African American
by the name of Troy Davis who murdered a White American Police Officer, Mark
MacPhail and a White Supremacist named Lawrence Brewer who murdered an African
American man, James Byrd Jr. were both executed by lethal injection in the U.S State of Georgia and Texas respectively. I blogged about them last year on the
date the two executions occurred.
I would like to write a
rebuttal essay to Comedian Dick Gregory’s words when he protested Lawrence Brewer’s
execution.
"Any state killing is wrong," he said. "If Adolf Hitler were to be executed, I would be here to protest … I believe life in prison is punishment. Execution is revenge."
A headline in the U.S. Army newspaper Stars and Stripes announcing Hitler's death. |
Please see this video to hear what Dick Gregory said. (SOURCE: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=se7FStbDOgw):
I was disturbed and I could not (at
first) believe what I had heard that Dick Gregory would protest even if The
Fuhrer were to be executed. I never heard any abolitionist cry over the Nazi
War Criminals when they were hanged after World War II. Gregory’s statement on
Hitler made me felt so flabbergasted.
|
As
we all know that Adolf Hitler had committed suicide on 30 April 1945, thus he
could not be sentenced to death for his war crimes. The late British Prime
Minister, Winston Churchill, noted at a Cabinet
meeting in December 1942:
"Contemplate that if Hitler falls into our hands we shall certainly put him to death. This man is the mainspring of evil. Instrument — electric chair, for gangsters, no doubt available on lease-lend'.”
Lawrence
Brewer was a Neo Nazi who was put to death for the murder of an African
American man. For Dick Gregory to say that he would protest Hitler’s execution,
is as good (obviously) as saying that he would protest any Neo Nazi’s
execution. Life in prison is punishment, Execution is revenge? NO WAY! I do not
buy that at all. How can he approve of a murderer being allowed to keep his own
life when he has taken another? Immanuel Kant will answer that for sure.
All
killing is wrong? Why not Dick Gregory protest against abortion, where the
innocent unborn are all being killed? Is Dick Gregory a Pacifist? He should
protest every war, including a defensive war. If Gregory had got the U.S
government to say that all killing was wrong during World War II, innocent
people in America would be gassed to death every day because the State refused
to protect their country against Nazi Germany.
English:
Adolf Hitler delivers a speech at the Kroll Opera House
to the men of the Reichstag on the subject of Roosevelt and the war in the
Pacific, declaring war on the United States. Next to Hitler in the government
benches (from right to left) are Joachim von
Ribbentrop, Erich Raeder, Walther von
Brauchitsch, Wilhelm Keitel,
Wilhelm Frick and Joseph Goebbels. In the second row (from
right to left) are Lutz
Graf Schwerin von Krosigk, Walther Funk, Richard Walther
Darré, Bernhard Rust,
Hanns Kerrl, Hans Frank, Julius Dorpmüller,
Arthur
Seyss-Inquart and Fritz Todt. In
the third row (from right to left) are Alfred Rosenberg, Otto Meißner and Johannes Popitz. (11 December 1941)
|
If
Adolf Hitler was tried under Texas Law, he would definitely be put to death, as
he had committed First Degree Murder. I suspect that no abolitionist will cry
even if Hitler were to be executed in Texas. If Dick Gregory claims that all
killing is wrong, why did he not protest against Osama Bin Laden’s assassination on May 2, 2011?
|
No comments:
Post a Comment